Edit 7/19/2015 (v 1.4.1): When we upgraded to this new version, app crashed twice while upgrading the database (third try was successful), and once after it got through the welcome screens. It seems the developers still have not fixed the app crashing problem.
This is a great app with a few issues. I am hoping they get resolved in future updates. We have a youth group of about 90 students, so it has been interesting seeing all the statistics from different schools, though right now I am not sure if any of the information is actionable. In other words, are we going to do ministry any differently armed with these attendance records? Or is this more just something cool to have? (And I’m perfectly fine with this just being cool to have)
<br><br>
Issues:<br><br>
1. Far too many required fields just to enter a student’s information. IMHO none of the information needs to be mandatory, except for perhaps a first name (yes then some of the stats are less accurate, but allow us users to make that decision, please don’t make it for us). New students were understandably uncomfortable with giving out their birthdates, let alone allow a picture to be taken of them. We’re a church, talk about creepy. We gamed the system by entering fake information for email, phone, and picture (we just take a picture of the ceiling).
<br><br>
2. UI is inconsistent and cluttered in entering student information: Some background fields are blue, some are red, there is no visible cue for the user on which are required until they try to go to the next screen and it throws up a flag. And for that matter, why not have all fields on the same page? Why make us click “Next” needlessly a few times to get all the screens? We can scroll! (and if you’re going to keep the “Next” paradigm, please make it larger for those of us on iPads?<br><br>
3. Here’s a curious UI choice: When you get to the final screen for student entry, you are required to take a picture, you can’t choose a picture from the camera roll. BUT, when you go to edit a student’s information, you NOW have a choice of either taking another picture OR using a picture from the cameral roll. Why not allow us that option on the final page of the data entry for a new student to begin with?<br><br>
4. App crashes randomly, usually when loading up student pictures.<br><br>
5. App does not cache images (student pictures) consistently. During attendance taking with students in either grid or list view, if you scroll down, and THEN back up, the pictures that were INITIALLY loaded need to load AGAIN. It’s very slow and laggy (we are using an iPad Mini 3). I’ve tested this a few times, and to be fair sometimes the images DO stay in place while scrolling.<br><br>
6. Price is probably on the high side for what it does and the amount of bugs it has.<br><br>
7. Parent/Guardian phone number does not automatically format into the (xxx) xxx-xxxx format like the Student info does.<br><br>
<br><br>
Future:<br><br>
1. Allow users to import a CSV file with all the fields of student information. That could open this app up to larger churches.<br><br>
2. Allow the default state of which camera (front or rear) to be saved. We have a student that goes around to take attendance, so we usually use the rear-facing camera (better quality, more ergonomic for a third party to take a picture, etc.). It’s annoying to always have to switch the camera each time we get to that screen. <br><br>
3. Would be nice when you select a particular student you could see all the events they have attended, with filters, etc.<br><br>
Even with these concerns, I see great potential for this app, and we will continue to use this app. Kudos to the developers for a great first try. My understanding is that they are continually looking to improve, and it can only get better from here. Thank you for helping us in ministry for us youth leaders!